Archive for life philosophy

Resident Evil 5 Isn’t Racist, But You Probably Are

Posted in Games with tags , , , , on March 18, 2009 by zolthanite

Intentionally inflammatory title for what I perceive as a completely ludicrous subject.  It’s like they have no idea what Resident Evil is about, nor keep it in context.

This was cross-posted at Twenty Sided in response to Shamus’ original article.


I’m going to paraphrase a story that one of my old bosses, Robert, told me. Regardless of veracity, it holds particular weight with this whole debate.

There was a time, long long ago, when Colin Powell was being interviewed as an up and coming African American in the Army (I believe this was before he became a general). One of the questions asked of him was, roughly: “What is your feeling about racism in the Armed Forces?”

His response: “I have not had a problem with racism in the Army.”

After the press conference, Robert was in Powell’s office, as he was Robert’s commanding officer, on unrelated business. But it was fairly obvious the interview didn’t sit well with him, and as he was leaving Powell stopped him and said, “Did you have a problem with what I said?” in reference to Powell’s response.

“Sir, I think that to say that racism has not been a problem in your career is quite honestly a lie. I don’t think any black person in the Army, myself included, would agree with you on that point.”

“Robert, racism is not something I have a problem with because I am not racist. The people who have a problem with racism are racist themselves. Racism is their problem, not mine.”

Bottom line is: Personal bias for the person playing the game is irrelevant, especially if they are hyper-sensitive to such issues. The baseline for racism is purely about intent, not about perspective.

As far as the intent goes, I would almost claim that because the game is devoid of artistic merit it doesn’t have to deal with the problem of racism or not. Birth of a Nation is not purely derivative entertainment, and actually is blatantly racist as it goes out of its way to elevate white people at the cost of black people. Using blackface, in most capacities (beyond a production of Othello or historical reenactment.  It’s a matter of context), actually is racist because someone actively is making race an issue.

Resident Evil 5 takes the zombie menace, and puts it in Africa. Unless it’s taking place in South Africa with tons of Dutch around, arguing about black zombies is ridiculous. Every Resident Evil has taken place, in some capacity, in the middle of nowhere. Raccoon City was a middle of nowhere town. The first RE (I believe) was in a middle-of-nowhere mansion. RE4 was in the unnamed, generic isolated Spanish countryside. RE5 is in Africa somewhere. What other ethnic group would you expect to find? This is dictated by setting, not because someone said “Oh we need to mow down some black people. We can’t do Harlem, so let’s go to Africa. I hear they have loads of  <insert racial slur in plural form>.”

As far as racist imagery, I don’t see pearly white smiles. I don’t see large lips and shuffle dancing. I don’t see anything that would indicate historically offensive paradigms, especially for the US, that’s no worse than your average box of Uncle Ben’s rice or Aunt Jemima’s pancake mix. To be frank, I don’t see anything different from Resident Evil 4 beyond a meaningful change in scenery appropriate for the setting. More importantly, for such a White Is Right game, why is the female lead not also white? Shouldn’t she also be lily fresh, blonde, and sexy to make the battle for white supremacy complete? She isn’t Asian, that’s for sure.

If anything, one could look at Japanese games as a whole and wonder, if they have any fault at all, why they elevate Western European features as a form of beauty as they do. Ken from SFIV is actually Japanese-origin, but wants to be American to the point where he bleaches his hair. I don’t remember playing a single RE where an Asian features prominently anywhere, except for Ada Wong, who isn’t exactly a positive role model for heroism. Is she a symbol of Japanese self-loathing? It would be a much more fruitful discussion. Cherry-picking RE5 for being racist out of the entire series is irresponsible for any real discussion.



Posted in Science with tags , , , , , on January 31, 2009 by zolthanite

Not really a post today, except to mention that I’m going to be running off to play Broomball in a few hours.  So I’m going to reproduce one of my old posts (Date: Nov 17, 2007) about engineering and what it means to me.  Enjoy:


Today, at 9AM PST, my Numerical Linear Algebra professor died of acute myeloid leukimia. From what I understand, he has no wife, no children, as his family was his colleagues and students. Gene Golub, for lack of any other way to express what he has achieved in his lifetime, has been one of the most influential mathematicians in the world. It is because of a seminar he gave when I was a junior that I am here, studying mathematical modeling in order to find a way for my interests to better the world in the broadest way possible. But for the non-academic community, he probably has a much more significant impact than you would ever know, unless someone told you.

Gene’s crowning achievement is a numerically stable version of singular value decomposition for matrices. This means absolutely nothing to anyone that posts on these forums, much less can read it. It’s a series of black magic operations that I’m still not privy to, but I respect it all the same. However, what I can tell you is that even in the most elementary of ways, the SVD is the most important tool that we have access to as engineers, and we don’t even realize it exists.

I am fairly certain that for gamers in particular, he may be indirectly the reason that we can have a game like Far Cry 2, which will supposedly support real-world physical models correlating the the weather (Assuming they use real formulas to do so). Even beyond that, the people that work tirelessly on computer architecture and hardware, that have to create simulated models of disturbingly complex and empirical systems based on quantum mechanics to minimize the costs associated with fabrication facilities that cost in upwards of billions of dollars, have depended on his methods as much as anyone else. In a sense, we probably owe a lot of our modern processing power to, and people like, Gene. But it extends much farther from there.

Some of us are going to be driving to P2KX. Some of us will be flying. Do we know how much work goes into designing these things? If your car is American, it’s probably a series of well-educated guesses, formulated on prior work and knowledge with a little bit of “git ‘er dun” work at some point to meet a deadline. If you’re flying a 737 out of O’Hare to Niagra, you can narrow most of that work down to people like Anthony Jameson, who spent years of his life working for Boeing on fluid dynamics models that have served as the very basis for designing almost every aircraft that leave their doors for almost the past three decades.

In a related vein, one of my classmates is currently doing some research work for an adjunct professor that works full-time at Lockheed Martin. He is currently doing analysis on the wing models for a satellite they are about to launch within the year, attempting to determine if the satellite will fly successfully or completely self-destruct on itself in orbit over the Earth. Like the air flow models, or any other physical model for that matter, what determines this is the eigenvalues of a series of partial differential equations. Typically, we only care about the principle eigenvalue, as it is the largest and dictates the overall behavior of your system.

One of the ways the principle eigenvalue can be found is by performing the SVD.

Yet the world, as a whole, will never know, or usually care who Gene Golub is. As global technology has advanced, much like gaming, we forget the producers, the programmers, the mathematicians, the very people that allow us to push the limits of our imaginations and create a way for men to pretend they are women in World of Warcraft or Final Fantasy, or use GMail to contact a long lost friend and visit them using an e-ticket purchased over Orbitz instantly with an instantly verifiable Visa through your Starbucks Wi-Fi connection.

To be an engineer, a scientist, a researcher, means to spend your entire life dedicated to your craft in a way that many people would find staggeringly oppressive. If you work in industry, you rarely get credit for the work you do outside your department, with all of the accolades granted to the company, not you. If you work in academia, your work is largely ignored by industry, letting most of your results fall by the wayside, unless you are fortunate enough to have someone from the corporate labs division read your work and make the effort of pitching it to marketing and applying the effort to get theory turned to practice. But somehow, we never seem to stop caring and loving what we do.

Gene is by far the best of these people I have ever had the pleasure of meeting, and I know the worldwide academic community as a whole will miss his presence in a way I cannot even begin to fathom. Not only a brilliant person, but a wonderful personality and a genuinely great person to be around. He is the only person I know who presented research results as if a real person who poured his heart and soul into his work was responsible for them, and not as if it was merely a result that sprang from the ether with a name attached to the side packaging. My only wish in life is that I am able to be half the professor he was during his lifetime, and inspire those around me as he has inspired countless others during his lifetime.

Gene, I will see you in class in a week and a half.